English-language reports on Honduras coup
- Log in to post comments
By Eva Golinger
[As of 11:15 am, June 28, Caracas time, President Manuel Zelaya is speaking live on Telesur from San Jose, Costa Rica. He has verified the soldiers entered his residence in the early morning hours, firing guns and threatening to kill him and his family if he resisted the coup. He was forced to go with the soldiers who took him to the air base and flew him to Costa Rica. He has requested the US government make a public statement condemning the coup, otherwise, it will indicate their compliance. At 5 pm, Roberto Micheletti, head of Honduras' Congress was sworn in as de facto president. At 7 pm, the Organization of American States condemned the coup. US secretary of state Hillary Clinton has formally condemned the coup. For continuing updates, visit Eva Golinger's web site at http://www.chavezcode.com/.]
June 28, 2009 -- Caracas, Venezuela -- The text message that beeped on my cell phone this morning read: “Alert, Zelaya has been kidnapped, coup d’etat underway in Honduras, spread the word.” It’s a rude awakening for a Sunday morning, especially for the millions of Hondurans who were preparing to exercise their sacred right to vote today for the first time on a consultative referendum concerning the future convening of a constitutional assembly to reform the constitution. Supposedly at the centre of the controversary is today’s scheduled referendum, which is not a binding vote but merely an opinion poll to determine whether or not a majority of Hondurans desire to eventually enter into a process to modify their constitution.
Such an initiative has never taken place in the Central American nation, which has a very limited constitution that allows minimal participation by the people of Honduras in their political processes. The current constitution, written in 1982 during the height of the US administration’s dirty war in Central America, was designed to ensure those in power, both economic and political, would retain it with little interference from the people.
Zelaya, elected in November 2005 on the platform of Honduras’ Liberal Party, had proposed the poll be conducted to determine if a majority of citizens agreed that constitutional reform was necessary. He was backed by a majority of labour unions and social movements in the country. If the poll had occured, depending on the results, a referendum would have been conducted during the elections in November.
In fact, several days before the poll was to occur, Honduras’ Supreme Court ruled it illegal, upon request by the Congress, both of which are led by anti-Zelaya majorities, and members of the ultra-conservative party, National Party of Honduras (PNH). This move led to massive protests in the streets in favour of President Zelaya. On June 24, the president fired the head of the high military command, General Romeo Vásquez, after he refused to allow the military to distribute the electoral material for Sunday’s elections. Vásquez held the material under tight military control, refusing to release it even to the president’s followers, stating that the scheduled referendum had been determined illegal by the Supreme Court and therefore he could not comply with the president’s order. As in the Unted States, the president of Honduras is commander in chief and has the final say on the military’s actions, and so he ordered the general’s removal. Minister of Defence Angel Edmundo Orellana also resigned in response to this increasingly tense situation.
But the following day, Honduras’ Supreme Court reinstated General Vásquez to the high military command, ruling his firing as “unconstitutional’. Thousands poured into the streets of Honduras’ capital, Tegucigalpa, showing support for President Zelaya and evidencing their determination to ensure the June 28 non-binding referendum would take place. On June 26, the president and a group of hundreds of supporters, marched to the nearby air base to collect the electoral material that had been previously held by the military. That evening, Zelaya gave a national press conference along with a group of politicians from different political parties and social movements, calling for unity and peace in the country.
As of June 27, the situation in Honduras was reported as calm. But early Sunday morning, June 28, a group of approximately 60 armed soldiers entered the presidential residence and took Zelaya hostage. After several hours of confusion, reports surfaced claiming the president had been taken to a nearby airforce base and flown to neighbouring Costa Rica. No images have been seen of the president so far and it is unknown whether or not his life is still endangered.
President Zelaya’s wife, Xiomara Castro de Zelaya, speaking live on Telesur at approximately 10 am Caracas time, announced that in early hours of Sunday morning, the soldiers stormed their residence, firing shots throughout the house, beating and then taking the president. “It was an act of cowardness”, said the first lady, referring to the illegal kidnapping occuring during a time when no one would know or react until it was all over. Casto de Zelaya also called for the “preservation” of her husband’s life, indicating that she herself is unaware of his whereabouts. She claimed their lives are all still in “serious danger” and made a call for the international community to denounce this illegal coup d’etat and to act rapidly to reinstate constitutional order in the country, which includes the rescue and return of the democratically elected Zelaya.
Coup condemned
Presidents Evo Morales of Bolivia and Hugo Chávez of Venezuela have both made public statements on Sunday morning condemning the coup d’etat in Honduras and calling on the international community to react to ensure democracy is restored and the constitutional president is reinstated. Last Wednesday, June 24, an extraordinary meeting of the member nations of the Bolivarian Alternative for the Americas (ALBA), of which Honduras is a member, was convened in Venezuela to welcome Ecuador, Antigua and Barbados, and St. Vincent to its ranks. During the meeting, which was attended by Honduras’ Foreign Minister Patricia Rodas, a statement was read supporting President Zelaya and condemning any attempts to undermine his mandate and Honduras’ democratic processes.
Reports coming out of Honduras have revealed that the public television channel Canal 8 has been shut down by the coup forces. Just minutes ago, Telesur announced that the military in Honduras is shutting down all electricity throughout the country. Those television and radio stations still transmitting are not reporting the coup d’etat or the kidnapping of President Zelaya, according to Foreign Minister Patricia Rodas. “Telephones and electricity are being cut off”, confirmed Rodas just minutes ago via Telesur. “The media are showing cartoons and soap operas and are not informing the people of Honduras about what is happening.” The situation is eerily reminiscent of the April 2002 coup d’etat against President Chávez in Venezuela, when the media played a key role by first manipulating information to support the coup and then later blacking out all information when the people began protesting and eventually overcame and defeated the coup forces, rescuing Chávez (who had also been kidnapped by the military) and restoring constitutional order.
Honduras is a nation that has been the victim of dictatorships and massive US intervention during the past century, including several military invasions. The last major US government intervention in Honduras occured during the 1980s, when the Reagain administration funded death squads and paramilitaries to eliminate any potential “communist threats” in Central America. At the time, John Negroponte was the US ambassador in Honduras and was responsible for directly funding and training Honduran death squads that were responsible for thousands of people being disappeared and assassinated throughout the region.
On June 26, the Organization of American States (OAS) convened a special meeting to discuss the crisis in Honduras, later issuing a statement condeming the threats to democracy and authorising a convoy of representatives to travel to OAS to investigate further. Nevertheless, on June 26, US assistant secretary of state Phillip J. Crowley refused to clarify the US government’s position in reference to a potential coup against President Zelaya, and instead issued a more ambiguous statement that implied Washington’s support for the opposition to the Honduran president. While most other Latin American governments had clearly indicated their adamant condemnation of the coup plans underway in Honduras and their solid support for Honduras’ constitutionally elected president, Manual Zelaya, the US spokesperson stated the following, “We are concerned about the breakdown in the political dialogue among Honduran politicians over the proposed June 28 poll on constitutional reform. We urge all sides to seek a consensual democratic resolution in the current political impasse that adheres to the Honduran constitution and to Honduran laws consistent with the principles of the Inter-American Democratic Charter."
US role
As of 10:30 am on June 28, no further statements have been issued by the Washington concerning the military coup in Honduras. The Central American nation is highly dependent on the US economy, which ensures one of its top sources of income, the monies sent from Hondurans working in the US under the “temporary protected status” program that was implemented during Washington’s dirty war in the
1980s as a result of massive immigration to US territory to escape the war zone. Another major source of funding in Honduras is USAID, providing over US$50 million annually for “democracy promotion” programs, which generally supports NGOs and political parties favourable to US interests, as has been the case in Venezuela, Bolivia and other countries in the region. The Pentagon also maintains a military base in Honduras in Soto Cano, with approximately 500 troops and numerous airforce combat planes and helicopters.
Foreign Minister Rodas has stated that she has repeatedly tried to make contact with the US ambassador in Honduras, Hugo Llorens, who has not responded to any of her calls thus far. The modus operandi of the coup makes clear that Washington is involved. Neither the Honduran military, which is majority trained by US forces, nor the political and economic elite, would act to oust a democratically elected president without the backing and support of the US government.
President Zelaya has increasingly come under attack by the conservative forces in Honduras for his growing relationship with the ALBA countries, and particularly Venezuela and President Chávez. Many believe the coup has been executed as a method of ensuring Honduras does not continue to unify with the more leftist and socialist countries in Latin America.
[Eva Golinger is Venezuelan-American attorney, writer and investigator living in Caracas. She is author of The Chávez Code: Cracking US Intervention in Venezuela (2005) and Bush vs. Chávez: Washington's War on Venezuela.]
FEDERACIÓN SINDICAL MUNDIAL
Atenas, 28 de junio de 2009
Organización Internacional del Trabajo
Organización de Naciones Unidas
UNESCO
La Federación Sindical Mundial expresa su solidaridad con la clase trabajadora y el pueblo de Honduras. Condenamos el golpe de estado militar y pedimos la inmediata liberación de todos los detenidos. Apoyamos todas las movilizaciones populares y pedimos a la OIT, ONU y UNESCO que condenen el golpe de estado.
Solamente el pueblo está capacitado para decidir el presente y el futuro de su propio país y nadie más.
Hacemos un llamado a todos los afiliados y amigos de la FSM en Honduras para que luchen por las libertades democráticas y sindicales; por el progreso y la abolición de la explotación.
En nombre de los setenta millones de afiliados de la FSM en todo el mundo pedimos que cesen de inmediato las interferencias de la CIA en los asuntos internos de los estados.
Los pueblos de América Latina han padecido muchos problemas a causa de la política de los imperialistas y especialmente de la política de los EE.UU. Actualmente, en el siglo XXI, los pueblos y los trabajadores no toleran los métodos y las prácticas fascistas.
Los organismos internacionales no tienen derecho a mantenerse en silencio. Tienen el compromiso de actuar en favor de las justas peticiones del pueblo de Honduras.
El fascismo no conseguirá pasar.
La democracia ganará.
Solidaridad Internacional Obrera ya.
EL SECRETARIADO
40, Zan Moreas street, Athens 11745 GREECE
Tel. +302109214417, +302109236700, Fax +30210 9214517
www.wftucentral.org E-mails : info@wftucentral.org, international@wftucentral.org
Bolivarian Alliance for the Peoples of Our America (ALBA)
Proclamation of the
Extraordinary Presidential Council
Managua, Republic of Nicaragua 29 June 2009
On Sunday the 28th of June in early hours of the morning, when the
Honduran people were getting ready to exercise their democratic will through a
poll with a consultative character, promoted by the President of the Republic
Manuel Zelaya Rosales to deepen participative democracy, a group of hooded
soldiers, who affirmed they had received orders from the High Command of the
Armed Forces, assaulted the residence of President Zelaya, in order to kidnap
him, disappear him for a number of hours and later expel him violently from his
homeland.
Immediately, the people of Honduras reacted like the noble heirs of the legacy
of Francisco Morazán [1], in the streets of the cities and towns of Honduras.
From the early hours of the morning hundreds of electoral booths received
thousands of men and women who attended to exercise their right to vote, and on
being informed of the kidnapping of their president, spilled out onto the
streets to protest the coup d'etat, giving an example of heroism, to confront,
unarmed, the guns and tanks.
Through the screens of Telesur, they managed to break the national and
international silence that the dictatorship wanted to impose through closing
the state television channel and cutting the electricity supply, aiming to
conceal and justify the coup d'etat against their people and the international
community - demonstrating an attitude that recalls the worst epoch of the
dictatorships experienced in the 20th century in our continent.
With one single voice, the governments and peoples of the continent reacted
condemning the coup d'etat, making clear that in Honduras there is only one President
and one government: that of President Manuel Zelaya Rosales. At the same time,
we salute the declarations of condemnation, that from very early, other
governments of the world began to issue.
In the face of the urgency of the situation, the governments of the Bolivarian
Alliance for the Peoples of Our America immediately convoke an Extraordinary
Presidential Council, with the objective of agreeing on forceful actions to
defeat the coup d'etat in Honduras, to support the heroic people of Morazán and
to unconditionally re-establish the President Manuel Zelaya Rosales in his
legitimate duties.
After analyzing the circumstances which have produced this coup d'etat, in the
face of the gravity of the violations of International Law, the multilateral agreements
and the accords of our countries with the Republic of Honduras, and in view of
the categorical rejection that the international community has manifested in
front of the dictatorial government that is trying to impose itself, the member
countries of ALBA have decided to withdraw our Ambassadors and leave a minimum
expression of our diplomatic representation in Tegucigalpa until the legitimate
government of President Manuel Zelaya Rosales is reinstated in its duties.
Likewise we recognise as the only diplomatic representatives of Honduras in our countries, the personnel designated by President Zelaya. Under no circumstances will we accredit personnel designated by the usurpers.
Equally, as full
members of the various systems of integration of the continent, we insist that
our brother countries of UNASUR, SICA, CARICOM, the Rio Group, the UN and the
OAS proceed in the same way in the face of the assailants of the Honduran
people.
On the other hand, we have agreed to declare ourselves in permanent alert in
order to accompany the valiant people of Honduras in the actions of struggle
that they have convoked, and we invoke the content of Articles 2 and 3 of the
Political Constitution of the Republic of Honduras:
"Art. 2: Sovereignty corresponds to the People from which emanate all the Powers of the State that are exercised through representation. The Sovereignty of the People can also be exercised in a direct manner through a Plebiscite or Referendum. The supplanting of popular Sovereignty and the usurpation of the constituted powers are classified as crimes of Treason against the Fatherland. The responsibility in these cases is imprescriptible and can be deduced to the role or petition of any citizen."
"Art. 3: No one has to
obey neither a usurper government nor those who assume functions or public
employment through the force of arms or using measures or procedures that break
or fail to recognise that which the Constitution and the laws establish. The
acts verified by such authorities are invalid. The people have the right to
resort to insurrection in defense of constitutional order."
As well as the principles of International Law respect the acts of resistance
and rebellion of the people confronting the attempts at domination. To the
teachers, workers, women, youth, peasants, indigenous peoples, honest business
people, intellectuals and other actors of Honduran society, we assure that
together we will win a great victory against the coup plotters that aim to
impose themselves on the brave people of Francisco Morazán.
Invoking the spirit and though of Francisco Morazán, together with him, we
proclaim to the coup plotters: "Men, you who have abused the rights of the
people for a sordid and stingy interest! With you I speak, enemies of
independence and liberty. If our actions, aimed at acquiring a homeland, can
suffer a parallel to those Central Americans that you have persecuted and
exiled, I challenge you to present them. Those same people, who have been
humiliated, insulted, debased and betrayed so many times, that today are the arbiters of their destiny and ask for our advice,
those people will be your judge."
Those who are leading the coup d'etat must know that it will be impossible to prevail and to make fun of international justice, to which sooner or later they will be subjected. We call on the officials and the soldiers of the Armed Forces of Honduras to rectify and to put their weapons at the service of the people of Honduras and their general commander, President Jose Manuel Zelaya Rosales.
The member countries of ALBA, in consultation with the governments of the continent and with various institutions that guarantee the fulfilment of International Law, we are bringing forward measures so that the grave violations and the crimes that are being committed aren't gotten away with.
The only path that remains for the coup makers to abandon their attitude and to guarantee immediately, unconditionally, and definitely, the return of President Jose Manuel Zelaya Rosales to his constitutional functions.
The Republic of Honduras is a full member of ALBA, and likewise of other regional integration and multilateral organisations, whose membership demand respect of the sovereignty of the people and the constitution. These fundamental conditions, having been violated by the coup makers, the governments of ALBA have decided to maintain all the cooperation programs that we have pre-empted with Honduras through President Zelaya.
Likewise, we propose that punitive measures are applied by all the multilateral integration organisations and mechanisms, which would help to enforce the immediate return to constitutional order in Honduras and would bring about the principles of action that Jose Marti referred to when he said, "Each person does their duty, and nothing can defeat us."
The governments of ALBA declare ourselves in a permanent consultation session, with all the governments of the continent, in order to evaluate further joint actions that enable us to accompany the Honduran people in the re-establishment of legality and the restitution of the President Manuel Zelaya Rosales.
Two hundreds years since the historic gesture that our peoples have developed throughout the continent, following the timeless example of the General of free men Augusto Cesar Sandino, of Francisco Morazan and faithful to the word of The Liberator Simon Bolivar, we put our hope with the people of Honduras and the peoples of the world for the sureness of victory, as, "all the peoples of the world who have wrestled for freedom have, in the end, exterminated their tyrants."
[1] Central American statesman, lawyer, orator, and general born in Tegucigalpa, Honduras, in 1792
Translated by Kiraz Janicke and Tamara Pearson for Venezuelanalysis.com
Published on National Catholic Reporter (http://ncronline.org)
Jun. 29, 2009
By Linda Cooper and James Hodge
The general who overthrew the democratically elected president of Honduras is a two-time graduate of the U.S. Army School of the Americas, an institution that has trained hundreds of coup leaders and human rights abusers in Latin America.
Gen. Romeo Orlando Vásquez Velásquez toppled President Manuel Zelaya in a pre-dawn coup on Sunday, surrounding the presidential palace with more than 200 soldiers and tanks and tear-gassing a crowd outside. The president was abducted and taken to an Air Force base before being flown to Costa Rica.
The overthrow followed a showdown over a controversial term-limit referendum that was to have taken place the day of the coup.
The military moved quickly against media outlets in an attempt to stem the flow of news about the ouster and the protests that followed.
Jesuit Fr. Joe Mulligan provided NCR with a copy of an email he received about the media crackdown from fellow Jesuit, Fr. Ismael Moreno, director of Radio Progreso, the order’s radio station in Honduras.
The station was transmitting news about the coup Sunday morning when about 25 military troops stormed the building and ordered them to cancel their programming, the email said. While the soldiers were inside the station, a large group of people gathered outside to support the station’s personnel. The standoff was apparently resolved without violence, but the station had not resumed operations by Monday night. Meanwhile, protests were growing in the capital city of Tegucigalpa, and strikes were being planned by Zelaya supporters.
The events came as no shock to Maryknoll Fr. Roy Bourgeois, founder of SOA Watch, which has sought for years to shut down the Army school, which was closed in 2000 and re-opened as the Western Hemisphere Institute for Security Cooperation. “We’re not surprised. Vásquez is one of the key players, an SOA grad” who’s keeping alive the school’s nickname, “School of Coups.”
The overthrow is re-fueling the latest effort by US peace activists to shut the school once and for all. Eric LeCompte, the national organizer for SOA Watch, said there are two pieces of legislation that are gaining support.
One is Rep. Jim McGovern’s House Bill 2567, which calls for suspending operations at the SOA/WHINSEC and investigating the torture manuals and human rights abuses associated with the school.
The second is an amendment to the National Defense Authorization Act for FY 2010, which would force the release of the names of the school’s graduates, including their rank, country of origin and the courses they’ve taken.
While the Defense Department promised transparency when it re-opened SOA as WHINSEC, LeCompte said it has refused to release the names of the instructors and the graduates since 2005 — after it was revealed that the school was enrolling well-known human rights abusers. One — Salvadoran Col. Francisco del Cid Diaz, a 2003 graduate — was cited by the 1993 U.N. Truth Commission for commanding a unit that dragged people from their homes and shot them at point-blank range.
Last week the House approved the amendment, but the measure still has to survive a House and Senate conference committee later this summer.
In overthrowing the government Sunday, Vásquez Velásquez joins two other Honduran SOA graduates who deposed heads of state, Gen. Juan Melgar Castro and Gen. Policarpo Paz Garcia.
Melgar Castro ruled the country from 1975 to 1978, the years when two of his SOA underlings — Maj. Jose Enrique Chinchilla and Lt. Benjamin Plata — conducted an operation that tortured and executed two priests, Michael Cypher and Ivan Betancur. The priests’ bodies were thrown in a well along with two women and five peasants who were baked alive in bread ovens. The massacre took place on the Los Horcones hacienda, which was owned by the father of Manuel Zelaya, the Honduran president ousted Sunday.
Melgar was overthrown in 1978 by fellow SOA graduate, Paz Garcia, whom the U.S. Army installed into SOA’s “Hall of Fame” ten years later. Paz Garcia’s tenure was also marked by brutal military repression and the formation of Battalion 3-16, a military death squad that worked closely with the CIA in targeting suspected leftists in the ’80s. Paz Garcia’s military commander was another SOA grad, Gen. Gustavo Alvarez Martinez, who ran 3-16 and ordered the execution of Fr. James Carney, a U.S. missionary to Honduras.
The three Honduran generals fit into the larger picture of coup leaders trained by the U.S. Army school, which used to boast about how many of the school’s graduates had become heads of their countries.
The boasting, which stopped after the graduates’ undemocratic paths to power became better known, celebrated such figures as:
* Argentine Gen. Leopoldo Galtieri, who seized power in a bloody coup, bringing down another SOA grad, Gen. Roberto Viola, who came to power during Argentina’s Dirty War.
* Guatemalan dictator Gen. Efrain Rios Montt, who seized power in a coup in 1982 and conducted a scorched earth campaign against the Mayan Indians.
* Panamanian dictators Gen. Omar Torrijos, who overthrew a civilian government in a 1968 coup, and Gen. Manuel Noriega, a five-time SOA graduate, who ruled the country and dealt in drugs while on the CIA payroll.
* Ecuadoran dictator Gen. Guillermo Rodriguez, who overthrew the elected civilian government in 1972.
* Bolivian dictators Gen. Hugo Banzer Suarez, who seized power in a violent coup in 1971, and Gen. Guido Vildoso Calderon, who grabbed power in 1982.
* Peruvian strongman Gen. Juan Velasco Alvarado, who in 1968 toppled the elected civilian government.
In ousting the Honduran president Sunday, Vásquez Velásquez had the help of other SOA graduates, including Gen. Luis Javier Prince Suazo, the head of the Honduran Air Force.
Another two-time SOA grad, retired Gen. Daniel López Carballo, told CNN that the coup was justified because Venezuelan President Hugo Chávez would be running Honduras by proxy if the military had not acted.
Records show that Vásquez Velásquez took a basic combat arms course at SOA in 1976 and another course on small military units in 1984, while Prince Suazo took a 1996 course on joint operations.
President Zelaya — whom the Honduran Congress replaced Sunday with Roberto Micheletti — was a businessman who had leaned to the right when he was elected in 2006. Zelaya surprised many when he started to loosen the strong ties Honduras has had with the United States, which has controlled the country to such a degree that it was once called the U.S.S. Honduras.
Zelaya enjoyed wide support among the poor and union leaders, but increasingly drew the wrath of the powers that be and clashed with foreign oil companies and the U.S. Embassy when he sought to reduce the price of oil for Hondurans.
Restricted by law to a 4-year term, he attempted to have a referendum that would ask voters to change the constitution and permit a second presidential term. Zelaya said a single term makes it impossible to address long-standing poverty issues in a country where half of the residents live on less than one dollar a day and have little voice in how the government operates.
The controversy heated up when Zelaya dismissed a Supreme Court ruling that held that the referendum was illegal. “The court,” he said, “offers justice for the rich, the powerful and the bankers, but only causes problems for democracy.”
Zelaya had also replaced Vásquez Velásquez as Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces after he refused to give logistical support for the referendum.
The coup has brought wide-spread condemnation by world leaders, and the Organization of American States called for Zelaya's reinstatement.
U.N. General Assembly President Miguel D'Escoto Brockmann “categorically” condemned what he called “the criminal action by the army” and asked the U.N. to find a way to restore the president to power.
D'Escoto also called for President Obama to condemn the coup, noting that Obama announced a new policy toward Latin America at the Summit of the Americas in Trinidad last month. But he added, "Many are now asking if this coup is part of this new policy as it is well known that the army in Honduras has a history of total collaboration with the United States."
The U.S. has sent mixed signals about the coup. Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton said the US was not insisting that Zelaya be restored to office. But later, Obama stiffened his stand, calling for his return to power. Still, he stopped short of calling for sanctions or threatening a cut off of U.S. aid to the country.
Linda Cooper and James Hodge are the authors of Disturbing the Peace: The Story of Father Roy Bourgeois and the Movement to Close the School of the Americas.
WASHINGTON — President Obama on Monday strongly condemned the ouster of Honduras’s president as an illegal coup that set a “terrible precedent” for the region, as the country’s new government defied international calls to return the toppled president to power and clashed with thousands of protesters.
“We do not want to go back to a dark past,” Mr. Obama said, in which military coups override elections. “We always want to stand with democracy,” he added.
The crisis in Honduras, where members of the country’s military abruptly awakened President Manuel Zelaya on Sunday and forced him out of the country in his bedclothes, is pitting Mr. Obama against the ghosts of past American foreign policy in Latin America.
The United States has a history of backing rival political factions and instigating coups in the region, and administration officials have found themselves on the defensive in recent days, dismissing repeated allegations by President Hugo Chávez of Venezuela that the C.I.A. may have had a hand in the president’s removal.
Obama administration officials said that they were surprised by the coup on Sunday. But they also said that they had been working for several weeks to try to head off a political crisis in Honduras as the confrontation between Mr. Zelaya and the military over his efforts to lift presidential term limits escalated.
The United States has long had strong ties to the Honduras military and helps train Honduran military forces. Those close ties have put the Obama administration in a difficult position, opening it up to accusations that it may have turned a blind eye to the pending coup. Administration officials strongly deny the charges, and Mr. Obama’s quick response to the Honduran president’s removal has differed sharply from the actions of the Bush administration, which in 2002 offered a rapid, tacit endorsement of a short-lived coup against Mr. Chávez.
On June 2, Obama administration officials got a firsthand look at the brewing political battle when Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton traveled to Honduras for an Organization of American States conference. Mrs. Clinton met with Mr. Zelaya, and he reportedly annoyed her when he summoned her to a private room late in the night after her arrival and had her shake hands with his extended family.
During a more formal meeting afterward, they discussed Mr. Zelaya’s plans for a referendum that would have laid the groundwork for an assembly to remake the Constitution, a senior administration official said.
But American officials did not believe that Mr. Zelaya’s plans for the referendum were in line with the Constitution, and were worried that it would further inflame tensions with the military and other political factions, administration officials said.
Even so, one administration official said that while the United States thought the referendum was a bad idea, it did not justify a coup.
“On the one instance, we’re talking about conducting a survey, a nonbinding survey; in the other instance, we’re talking about the forcible removal of a president from a country,” the official said, speaking on the condition of anonymity during a teleconference call with reporters.
As the situation in Honduras worsened, Assistant Secretary of State Thomas A. Shannon Jr., along with Hugo Llorens, the American ambassador to Honduras, spoke with Mr. Zelaya, military officials and opposition leaders, administration officials said. Then things reached a boil last Wednesday and Thursday, when Mr. Zelaya fired the leader of the armed forces and the Supreme Court followed up with a declaration that Mr. Zelaya’s planned referendum was illegal.
The White House and the State Department had Mr. Llorens “talk with the parties involved, to tell them, ‘You have to talk your way through this,’ ” a senior administration official said Monday. “ ‘You can’t do anything outside the bounds of your constitution.’ ”
Still, administration officials said that they did not expect that the military would go so far as to carry out a coup. “There was talk of how they might remove the president from office, how he could be arrested, on whose authority they could do that,” the administration official said. But the official said that the speculation had focused on legal maneuvers to remove the president, not a coup.
Whether Mr. Zelaya merited removal remains a strong point of debate in Honduras. Fierce clashes erupted Monday between thousands of soldiers and thousands of Mr. Zelaya’s backers. The protesters blocked streets, set fires and hurled stones at the soldiers, who fired tear gas in response. But opponents of Mr. Zelaya said they intended to rally Tuesday in support of his ouster.
On the diplomatic front, three of the country’s neighbors — Guatemala, El Salvador and Nicaragua — said they would halt commerce along their borders for 48 hours. Beyond that, Venezuela and some of its allies, including Ecuador, Bolivia, Nicaragua and Cuba, said they were withdrawing their ambassadors from Honduras in an effort to isolate the new government. Brazil also said it had ordered its ambassador to Honduras, who was out of the country at the time of the coup, not to return until further notice.
In the face of criticism from across the hemisphere, the new government hunkered down in Mr. Zelaya’s old office, ringed by soldiers and defending its actions as a bid to save the country’s democracy, not undermine it.
Roberto Micheletti, the veteran congressional leader who was sworn in by his fellow lawmakers on Sunday to replace Mr. Zelaya, seemed to plead with the world to understand that Mr. Zelaya’s arrest by the army had been under an official arrest warrant based on his flouting of the Constitution.
“We respect the whole world, and we only ask that they respect us and leave us in peace,” Mr. Micheletti said in a radio interview, noting that previously scheduled elections called for November would go on as planned.
Mr. Zelaya said from Nicaragua late Monday that he would return to Honduras on Thursday with the secretary general of the Organization of American States, José Miguel Insulza, Reuters reported.
“He’s the former president of Honduras now,” said Ramón Abad Custodio, the president of the National Commission of Human Rights, who defends the replacement of Mr. Zelaya as constitutional. “He may feel like he’s still president, but he’s a common citizen now.”
Helene Cooper reported from Washington, and Marc Lacey from Tegucigalpa, Honduras. Simon Romero contributed reporting from Bogotá, Colombia, Elisabeth Malkin from Mexico City, and Blake Schmidt from Managua, Nicaragua.Tuesday, June 30, 2009 4:26 PM
Denounce the Human Rights Abuses in Honduras
The situation in Honduras turned violent when over 10,000 people gathered in the
streets to protest the coup Monday evening. Using tear gas, high-powered water
and guns (it is still not clear whether soldiers were armed with rubber bullets
or otherwise) many people were wounded and there has been one confirmed death in the capital, Tegucigalpa.
In the capital, pro-coup marches are occurring, defended by the police and
national guard. As of Tuesday morning, the resistance movement to the coup is
gathering in Tegucigalpa, to determine how and where to take to the streets.
Therefore, there is anticipation of violence today, as soldiers are expected to
react violently today to protesters as they did yesterday.
Violence has also broken out outside of Tegucigalpa.
In the interior of the
country, especially in the state of Olancho, the military has been conducting
home invasions in order to capture and detain youth. Many youth have fled to
the mountains, and their whereabouts are unknown.
The military is violently disbursing pro-Zelaya marches, and many protesters are
missing. The local media is refusing to air any comments about the violence
and human rights abuses taking place in the country, insisting that nothing is
amiss.
An international news crew from TeleSur was detained and beaten while
broadcasting the oppression of protesters by the military.
Yesterday in a meeting of the Rio Group, President Zelaya reiterated that he is
the only president of Honduras, and that he has not stepped down. He declared
his plans to return to Honduras on Thursday, mostly likely accompanied by the
Secretary-General of the Organization of American States (OAS), Jose Miguel
Insulza. Argentine president Cristina Fernandez also plans to accompany Zelaya
on Thursday.
The coup in Honduras has been unanimously condemned throughout the Western
Hemisphere, and has also been condemned by the United Nations and European
Union. Zelaya spoke on Tuesday in front of the United Nations.
Notably, two army battalions have refused orders from the coup government. They
are the Fourth Infantry Battalion in the city of Tela and the Tenth Infantry
Battalion in La Ceiba (the second largest city in Honduras), both located in the
state of Atlantida.
The coup leaders include several well-known human rights abusers, such as the
retired Captain Billy Fernando Joya Amendola, who was a member of the
CIA-trained 3-16 batallion from 1984-91, one of the most notorious battalions
noted for human rights abuses during that time.
Bertha Oliva, of COFADEH, calls the coup advisers a line-up of the "Galley of
Terror".
Furthermore, two coup leaders, Air Force Commander General Luis Javier Prince
Suazo and Army General Romeo Vasquez Velasquez, were trained at the School of
the Americas (SOA, renamed the Western Hemisphere Institute for Security
Cooperation), a US army school located in Fort Benning, GA, whose graduates have
been linked to some of the largest human rights atrocities in Latin America's
history.
COFADEH (Comite de Familiares de Detenidos y Desaparecidos en Honduras or the Honduran Committee of Families of the Disappeared or Detained), a leading Human Rights group in Honduras, has gone hospital to hospital attempting to document the cases of violence and human rights abuses. They are conducting this
documentation work because the national Human Rights Commission, headed by Ramon Custodio and the Fiscal (Attorney General), Sandra Ponce, have thus far refused to document and denounce human rights abuses since the coup began Monday morning and are fully supporting the coup government.
One of the first moves of the army and de facto government was to cut
electricity and telephone lines throughout most of the country. Later Monday two
television channels were re-established, both of which maintained that Zelaya
had voluntary resigned, the change of power was constitutionally legitimate and
that the new President had the support of the majority of the Honduran people.
Through TeleSur, a transnational South American television news station, the
public in South America has been able to see on the ground footage of protests
in Honduras as well as streamed footage from the Honduran pro-coup news
stations.
Hondurans within their country are much less informed than larger Latin America
because the coup government has been able to stop TeleSur from broadcasting.
Information is arriving to Honduran people about the whereabouts of President
Manuel Zelaya and the vast international support he has by way of people from
outside Honduras calling to cell phones of friends and family inside who are
inside the country. The biggest issue now are human rights abuses inside the
country.
COFADEH calls on the international human rights community to denounce the
blatant disregard of human rights abuses by Ramon Custodio and Sandra Ponce.
Bertha Oliva, of COFADEH, is available for interviews (in Spanish) by the
media. She can be reached in Honduras at 011-504-8991-0259 (cell) or
011-501-222-7144 (land line).
Zelaya attempted to give Hondurans the gift of participatory
democracy. It was the coup leaders who violated the constitution. Those
who say otherwise are wrong.
By Alberto Valiente Thoresen, RebelReports Guest Contributor
EDITOR’S NOTE: RebelReports is publishing this original article as a response to those who claim that the coup in Honduras was legal and/or constitutional and to the reporting by those media outlets that consistently repeat false characterizations of Honduran law and President Zelaya’s actions.—JS
In the classic Greek tragedy, Prometheus Bound, the playwright
observes: “Of wrath’s disease wise words the healers are.” Shortly put,
this story is about Prometheus, a titan who was punished by the
almighty gods for having given humanity the capacity to create fire.
This generated a conflict, which ended with Prometheus’ banishment and
exile.
Currently, there is a tragedy being staged in the Central
American republic Honduras. Meanwhile, the rest of humanity follows the
events, as spectators of an outdated event in Latin America, which
could set a very unfortunate undemocratic precedent for the region. In
their rage, the almighty gods of Honduran politics have punished an
aspiring titan, President Manuel Zelaya, for attempting to give
Hondurans the gift of participatory democracy. This generated a
constitutional conflict that resulted in president Zelaya’s banishment
and exile. In this tragedy, words are once again the healers of
enraged minds. If we, the spectators, are not attentive to these
words, we risk succumbing intellectually, willfully accepting the facts
presented by the angry coup-makers and Honduran gods of politics.
In
this respect, media coverage of the recent military coup in Honduras is
often misleading; even when it is presenting a critical standpoint
towards the events. Concentrating on which words are used to
characterize the policies conducted by President Zelaya might seem
trivial at first sight. But any familiarity to the notion of
‘manufacturing of consent’, and how slight semantic tricks can be used
to manipulate public opinion and support, is enough to realize the
magnitude of certain omissions. Such oversights rely on the public’s
widespread ignorance about some apparently minor legal intricacies in
the Honduran Constitution.
For example, most reports have stated
that Manuel Zelaya was ousted from his country’s presidency after he
tried to carry out a non-binding referendum to extend his term in
office. But this is not completely accurate. Such presentation of
“facts” merely contributes to legitimizing the propaganda, which is
being employed by the coup-makers in Honduras to justify their actions.
This interpretation is widespread in US-American liberal environments,
especially after Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said that the coup
is unacceptable, but that “all parties have a responsibility to address
the underlying problems that led to [Sunday]’s events.” However,
President Zelaya cannot be held responsible for this flagrant violation
of the Honduran democratic institutions that he has tried to expand.
This is what has actually happened:
The Honduran Supreme Court
of Justice, Attorney General, National Congress, Armed Forces and
Supreme Electoral Tribunal have all falsely accused Manuel Zelaya of
attempting a referendum to extend his term in office.
According
to Honduran law, this attempt would be illegal. Article 239 of the
Honduran Constitution clearly states that persons, who have served as
presidents, cannot be presidential candidates again. The same article
also states that public officials who breach this article, as well as
those that help them, directly or indirectly, will automatically lose
their immunity and are subject to persecution by law. Additionally,
articles 374 and 5 of the Honduran Constitution of 1982 (with
amendments of 2005), clearly state that: “it is not possible to reform
the Constitution regarding matters about the form of government,
presidential periods, re-election and Honduran territory”, and that
“reforms to article 374 of this Constitution are not subject to
referendum.”
Nevertheless, this is far from what President
Zelaya attempted to do in Honduras the past Sunday and which the
Honduran political/military elites disliked so much. President Zelaya
intended to perform a non-binding public consultation, about the
conformation of an elected National Constituent Assembly. To do this,
he invoked article 5 of the Honduran “Civil Participation Act” of
2006. According to this act, all public functionaries can perform
non-binding public consultations to inquire what the population thinks
about policy measures. This act was approved by the National Congress
and it was not contested by the Supreme Court of Justice, when it was
published in the Official Paper of 2006. That is, until the president
of the republic employed it in a manner that was not amicable to the
interests of the members of these institutions.
Furthermore, the
Honduran Constitution says nothing against the conformation of an
elected National Constituent Assembly, with the mandate to draw up a
completely new constitution, which the Honduran public would need to
approve. Such a popular participatory process would bypass the current
liberal democratic one specified in article 373 of the current
constitution, in which the National Congress has to approve with 2/3 of
the votes, any reform to the 1982 Constitution, excluding reforms to
articles 239 and 374. This means that a perfectly legal National
Constituent Assembly would have a greater mandate and fewer limitations
than the National Congress, because such a National Constituent
Assembly would not be reforming the Constitution, but re-writing it.
The National Constituent Assembly’s mandate would come directly from
the Honduran people, who would have to approve the new draft for a
constitution, unlike constitutional amendments that only need 2/3 of
the votes in Congress. This popular constitution would be more
democratic and it would contrast with the current 1982 Constitution,
which was the product of a context characterized by counter-insurgency
policies supported by the US-government, civil façade military
governments and undemocratic policies. In opposition to other legal
systems in the Central American region that (directly or indirectly)
participated in the civil wars of the 1980s, the Honduran one has not
been deeply affected by peace agreements and a subsequent reformation
of the role played by the Armed Forces.
Recalling these
observations, we can once again take a look at the widespread
assumption that Zelaya was ousted as president after he tried to carry
out a non-binding referendum to extend his term in office.
The
poll was certainly non-binding, and therefore also not subject to
prohibition. However it was not a referendum, as such public
consultations are generally understood. Even if it had been, the
objective was not to extend Zelaya’s term in office. In this sense, it
is important to point out that Zelaya’s term concludes in January
2010. In line with article 239 of the Honduran Constitution of 1982,
Zelaya is not participating in the presidential elections of November
2009, meaning that he could have not been reelected. Moreover, it is
completely uncertain what the probable National Constituent Assembly
would have suggested concerning matters of presidential periods and
re-elections. These suggestions would have to be approved by all
Hondurans and this would have happened at a time when Zelaya would have
concluded his term. Likewise, even if the Honduran public had decided
that earlier presidents could become presidential candidates again,
this disposition would form a part of a completely new constitution.
Therefore, it cannot be regarded as an amendment to the 1982
Constitution and it would not be in violation of articles 5, 239 and
374. The National Constituent Assembly, with a mandate from the people,
would derogate the previous constitution before approving the new one.
The people, not president Zelaya, who by that time would be
ex-president Zelaya, would decide.
It is evident that the
opposition had no legal case against President Zelaya. All they had was
speculation about perfectly legal scenarios which they strongly
disliked. Otherwise, they could have followed a legal procedure
sheltered in article 205 nr. 22 of the 1982 Constitution, which states
that public officials that are suspected to violate the law are subject
to impeachment by the National Congress. As a result they helplessly
unleashed a violent and barbaric preemptive strike, which has
threatened civility, democracy and stability in the region.
It
is fundamental that media channels do not fall into omissions that can
delay the return of democracy to Honduras and can weaken the
condemnation issued by strong institutions, like the United States
government. It is also important that individuals are informed, so that
they can have a critical attitude to media reports. Honduras needs
democracy back now, and international society can play an important
role in achieving this by not engaging in irresponsible
oversimplifications.
Alberto Valiente Thoresen was born in
San Salvador, El Salvador. He currently resides in Norway where he
serves on the board of the Norwegian Solidarity Committee with Latin
America
Coup in Honduras: President Zelaya Ousted by Military
https://nacla.org/node/5947
Resistance and Repression in Honduras
http://narcosphere.narconews.com/notebook/kristin-bricker/2009/06/resistance-and\
-repression-honduras
Venezuelan, Cuban, and Nicaraguan Ambassadors to Honduras Kidnapped
http://www.venezuelanalysis.com/news/4556
Honduras: Indigenous people condemn plot
http://www.greenleft.org.au/2009/800/41204
Honduras: Military Coup a Blow to Democracy
http://www.hrw.org/en/news/2009/06/28/honduras-military-coup-blow-democracy
"In Solidarity with the Organizations of Via Campesina and the People of
Honduras"
http://www.narconews.com/Issue57/article3581.html
North American Imperialism and the Extreme Right are Behind Coup in Honduras:
Chavez
http://www.venezuelanalysis.com/news/4555
Demand a Call from Barack Obama for the Reinstatement of Honduran President
Zelaya
http://salsa.democracyinaction.org/o/727/t/3823/campaign.jsp?campaign_KEY=27531
"We Will Not Be Silenced or Humiliated"
http://www.narconews.com/Issue57/article3580.html
Honduran Congress names provisional president
http://www.upi.com/turl-88b6a3/
RT - Military Coup in Honduras
http://rightsaction.org/Alerts/Honduran_coup_062809.html